Navigate Select ESC Close

1964, Government Takes Farm Against Owner's Will. Filmmakers Record it.

2026-05-07 News & Politics
2.2k
146
45
David Hoffman
David Hoffman
1.4m subscribers

Unlock all features

FREE: Get instant access to 10 AI summaries, chats, or transcripts per day.

Description

This is farmer Eber Pisel of Chambersburg, Pennsylvania back in 1964. The Army Corps of Engineers was trying to save the Potomac River and the flooding and water pollution that was taking place downriver in Washington DC. Their plan was to build a group of dams upriver and one of those dams was going to be built on Mr. Pisels' family farm, a farm which had been in his family for generations. I have several times in my life seen the government take land by eminent domain including land for highways and other state and federal construction. They say they pay a fair price but in my experience, that isn't always the case. The main reason why this didn't go through wasn't because the farmers in the area tried to fight, although they did, but because it got more and more and more expensive and the government has less and less money available to build the project. Today you certainly couldn't drink out of the Potomac River downstream in Washington DC and I don't know what happened regarding the flooding situation that they were trying to fix by the dam project. As the years progressed, the estimated costs for the dam projects skyrocketed. The government faced a shortage of funds to complete such a massive undertaking.Public Opposition: Farmers in the region and conservation groups fiercely fought the proposals.Result: Ultimately, the specific dam project that would have permanently flooded the Pisel family farm was never completed. Only two of the originally proposed 16 dams (most notably the Jennings Randolph Lake) were ever actually built.The story of Eber Pisel is often cited as a poignant example of the emotional and financial toll of eminent domain on multi-generational family farms, even when the underlying government projects fail to materialize.

Top Comments (10)

@genearbogast7525 2026-05-07

Thank You Mr. Hoffman for continuing to publish your work. It is timelessly excellent and relevant on many levels......

50
@toughlikerocks 2026-05-08

I'm reminded of something I read in a comment section of one of your other videos. These guys are of a generation that grew up taking rhetoric class in school, and it is so apparent. All of their arguments are so clear, concise, and well crafted.

16
@justthefactsmaam94 2026-05-08

Now we’re beginning to feel the pressure. Yes sir, indeed we are.

14
@newcures7813 2026-05-07

We gonna need your city for the new data center you don’t want. We’re gonna need your land to build the infrastructure to surveil you and enslave you after you’re all out of work. But don’t worry it’s in the “public interest”. And no need to worry about your children. You probably don’t have them anyway, and the chemicals we’ve been spraying are impacting your reproductive health and the embryological development of any offspring you did manage to produce. Oh, and the money we’re giving you in compensation for the land we steal, we’re gonna inflate it so you can’t afford to move anywhere or buy the GMO foods we’re gonna fill your grocery stores with.

52 1 replies
@bauhnguefyische667 2026-05-10

The sad part is those farms are probably now covered in tract house McMansion’s, Walmart and a strip mall with a Dollar Store.

10
@justthefactsmaam94 2026-05-08

Guy looks like he is missing an arm, and still working the land.

12
@jayhawkjd8565 2026-05-08

They took my grandfather's farm in Kansas for Lake Wakonda. He'd feed the hobos during the depression (the number "8" scratched on the fence post told others they had eaten there), had german POWs in WW2 (including the pianist from the Berlin philharmonic), set records for corn per acre (including my birth year of '59!) - but none of that and a million things more mattered to the damn dam engineers. RIP grandpa 1899-1969 - dead from the mustard gas cancer from WW1, fighting for our liberties, which ultimately he was denied.

46 3 replies
@r.williamcomm7693 2026-05-08

Thank you so much Mr. Hoffman. I lived in Chambersburg as a child.

3
@joecurmaci5880 2026-05-07

Look at the problems out west with Hoover dam and the other dams in reservoirs catastrophic every single time man thinks they could manage mother nature she throws a curveball at them that they just couldn't foresee

17
@FinnbogiRagnarRagnarsson 2026-05-11

So well spoken people.

2

Unlock the Data Inside
Turn Videos into Knowledge

  • Get FREE 10/day: transcripts, summaries, chats
  • Chat with videos, export text & PDF
  • $1 free API credit for RAG, chatbots & research

Free forever plan • All features unlocked

App screenshot