Navigate Select ESC Close

Notre Dame's CFP Snub Reaction + Bowl Game Opt-Out - Josh Pate's College Football Show

2025-12-10 Sports
48.8k
1.5k
1.2k

Notre Dame's CFP Snub: Process Failure vs. Program Reaction

Analyze why Notre Dame was correctly excluded from the College Football Playoff based on established criteria, yet severely misled by the committee's process, and evaluate the subsequent reaction from the Athletic Director.

Short Summary

  • Pate confirms the final CFP bracket adhered to current protocols, even if undesirable, by prioritizing head-to-head results between comparable teams.
  • The legitimate core grievance centers on the CFP Committee's "horrifically bungled" messaging, which misled Notre Dame leadership into expecting a spot.
  • Readers gain insight into separating subjective claims (who deserved to be in) from objective process critiques (how decisions were communicated).

Unlock all features

FREE: Get instant access to 10 AI summaries, chats, or transcripts per day.

Description

Notre Dame was left out of the College Football Playoff, and on Josh Pate's College Football Show Ep 696 Josh Pate delivered his initial reaction to the fallout from the Notre Dame Athletic Director as well as Notre Dame fans. What do we make of criticism towards the ACC? Did Notre Dame deserve to be in the CFP? Let us know what you think in the comments below and be sure to SUBSCRIBE to the channel and CLICK THE BELL for notifications as we bring you multiple live shows per week! #CFP #JoshPate #NotreDame SUBSCRIBE to the Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/josh-pates-college-football-show/id1485905502 Twitter: https://twitter.com/JoshPateCFB Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/JoshPateCFB/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@joshpatecfb

Top Comments (10)

@golddnn6299 2025-12-10

ND fan here. Miami 100% deserved to be in and they deserve that spot. My issue with the ACC is their bone headed tie breakers that kept Miami out of the conference championship game. If Miami wins that conference title and gets an autobid, then ND gets an at large bid. I’d like to think that’s why our AD was pissed, but I don’t know.

76 29 replies
@commonabond 2025-12-10

Gruden is right, the runner ups should be playing elimination games on Championship weekend instead of having a bye week.

74 6 replies
@ja1oo12o2o 2025-12-10

This biggest issue, as always, is the supposed criteria are applied inconsistently depending on the team

57 11 replies
@jakehr3 2025-12-10

I think if they remove the weekly ranking shows then all of this gets a lot less extreme Do what March Madness does and let the AP and Coaches polls do all the talking and then let Selection Sunday be the first and only time the playoff committee let's people know who's in and who's out

48 2 replies
@MortonGOS 2025-12-10

Bottom line the way the playoff is set up its not the best 12 teams.

19 1 replies
@na4489 2025-12-10

Good to know you can lose TWO unranked games, not even play in a conference championship and still make the playoffs 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

13 10 replies
@mfnflyw16 2025-12-10

Josh shouldn’t the committee weigh the fact that Miami and Alabama had wins against an FCS team and really only nine wins in the FBS. I thought the committee was going to.” discount.” Those. Obviously, tough decisions and the big culprits are a system that had the possibility of two group of five teams getting in and the ACC for their nerd algorithm tiebreaker system

12 9 replies
@xavierklaw 2025-12-10

I agree they were not robbed but they were definitely misled and I blame the committee wholeheartedly because they knew exactly what they were doing the Tuesday before when they dropped Notre Dame. They fully expected BYU to lose and that Miami was going to jump Notre Dame. There are so many issues with the current playoff system and guaranteeing certain spots where they shouldn't be guaranteed

12 1 replies
@mfnflyw16 2025-12-10

I don’t think Pete minded the ACC pushing Miami as much as they made it also against Notre Dame. Perhaps he mostly pissed how the ACC could so incredibly botch tiebreaker process. If game is 1st place UVA vs highest ranked ( Miami) then ND is in. Has to be thinking about Jim Phillips “ how could you be so stupid?”

10 4 replies
@waynemcvay9467 2025-12-10

ND did state that it was a team decision to opt out of the bowl invite.

2

Unlock the Data Inside
Turn Videos into Knowledge

  • Get FREE 10/day: transcripts, summaries, chats
  • Chat with videos, export text & PDF
  • $1 free API credit for RAG, chatbots & research

Free forever plan • All features unlocked

App screenshot