Navigate Select ESC Close

The Paper is Missing Something...

2025-09-10 Entertainment
34.0k
996
223
Just an Observation
Just an Observation
505.0k subscribers

Review of Peacock's 'The Paper': Why It Lacks Energy and Depth

Watch this review to discover why The Paper is merely watchable, not great, and exactly what major changes it needs to match The Office's comedic success.

Short Summary

  • The initial season lands as "fine" but lacks the necessary chaotic energy and strong character anchors—like Michael Scott—found in its predecessor.
  • Storylines could leverage the context of the collapsing news industry for crucial social commentary, which the show currently avoids.
  • Improvement is possible, especially given how much the US Office improved after Season 1, but The Paper must take calculated risks. This overview analyzes the tone, character dynamics, and narrative structure of the first season of The Paper, providing actionable advice for how the creators can inject vital comedic momentum.

Unlock all features

FREE: Get instant access to 10 AI summaries, chats, or transcripts per day.

Description

This video essay reviews Peacock's The Paper (a reboot of The Office) starring Domhnall Gleeson and Sabrina Impacciatore. The Office was a smash hit that ran for nine seasons (six of which were great) but can The Paper reach similar heights? In this video I look at the tone, characters and storylines to see where The Paper works and where it comes up short. The Paper is currently needlessly mediocre where it could have improved with some fixes. FAIR USE NOTICE: This video may contain copyright material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. This material is made available under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made "fair use" for the purposes such as criticism, comment, review, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that otherwise might be infringing. All rights belong to its owners. Music Used: A Brand New Start by TrackTribe (YouTube Audio Library) Who's Using Who? by The Mini Vandals (YouTube Audio Library) Take Me Out to the Ballgame by E's Jammy Jams (YouTube Audio Library) Under The Sun by Everet Almond (YouTube Audio Library) Timestamps: 0:00 The Paper Review 2:00 Energy and Characters 7:20 Storylines #thepaper #theoffice #videoessay

Top Comments (10)

@TheDubastro 2025-09-10

I don’t think it’s missing anything other than a second season to flesh everything out. I found the show to be entertaining and endearing. That’s all I needed

347 12 replies
@foxandeagle6790 2025-09-11

I think Abbot Elementary nalled the office vibe while still being its own original thing. It would be really cool if u made an analysis on the show because it really feels like the return of the classic sitcom. It also delves into real issues without being too preachy

114 9 replies
@tehbobb08 2025-09-10

Where are all the talking heads? It barely feels like there is a camera crew there, except when they look at the camera every now and then

106 6 replies
@JustanObservation 2025-09-10

Next video: Frank Reynolds from It's Always Sunny

95 6 replies
@bethanyduvall9860 2025-09-10

the characters being too mild and lacking interesting dynamics with one another was my main gripe. There needs to be more contrast and context. I found myself wondering "why am I watching these exact people exist in this exact setting?", and I don't think the first season had a real answer yet.

48
@smoogieboogie1694 2025-09-11

I don't have Peacock so I can't even watch this, but I am happy that they already confirmed a season 2. Both the Office and Parks and Rec notoriously had first seasons that people largely disliked, and they went on to become beloved sitcoms because they were given the chance to improve. Nowadays a lot of shows are axed after a lackluster first season and so we never get the chance to see anything better out of them.

48
@ineedfriends-podcast 2025-09-13

Skipping the 1st season of the US office is such a misstep 😭 Basketball, The Alliance... it's so good! Diversity Day might be in my top 5 episodes

30 3 replies
@Itscoacho 2025-09-11

They are too well adjusted lol

28
@geezlouise420 2025-09-12

8:26 That catfish episode felt most like a random The Office episode

13 1 replies
@deadairconversion 2025-09-13

There does seem like there is something “off” with the lighting. The Office had some depth in its visuals, but The Paper seems two dimensional and I can only attribute that to the lighting and maybe even the color contrast. Just seems very washed out

11

Unlock the Data Inside
Turn Videos into Knowledge

  • Get FREE 10/day: transcripts, summaries, chats
  • Chat with videos, export text & PDF
  • $1 free API credit for RAG, chatbots & research

Free forever plan • All features unlocked

App screenshot