r/Bestof My Boyfriend Tried to Murder My Dog

That second story, most people who read it don't believe the OP at all as a credible source. After all the updates, people think she's making everything up for views

2nd story: Anyone else getting a suspicion that the last update proving that OP was "right all along" was made up to make her look better. Seems awfully convenient for her.

For a bit of added context, the update to story 2 was removed from r/WhatShouldIDo. There’s no officially stated reason, but it’s probably due to being reported as fake.

Story 1: given the rise of popular media, the ex should have realized that killing someone's dog is a bad idea... Story 2: OP 100% cheated on her husband. EDIT: I....don't believe OP's edit. She freaked out on her husband and then she just secretly happens to find out the husband is cheating? I'm not saying it's not possible, but man it seems like "I overreacted, got roasted on reddit, and then made this up so I could be right."

Story 2: That last update seems a little too clean and convenient, the reason he came clean was because someone saw and was going to tell but didn't say anything until after hearing about it days (at least) later? that's a bit of a contradiction. He thought a head of time to use multiple apps so that if things went south he could push it onto her, AND she agreed to it know that's why? He also thought this far ahead but picked her up in front of the bar in full view of her friends which he knew were there? so he's both great at thinking ahead to cover his tracks AND blatantly flaunting what he's doing? Her initial horrible reaction (which is completely unlike her apparently) turns out to be completely justified because she knew on an instinctual level?

I think the last story she just got tired of being blasted in the comments and decided to make up an ending that make her look better. I don't believe her at all

Ah that first story is so good to hear Sticksie is okay in the end! I always had worries about that when I had my dog.

*1st Story:* My only working theory as to why Jay wanted snuff out OP's dog is because she mentioned that she had no other family (or at least none nearby) and they were in talks to moving closer to Jay's family. If Stixie were gone, Jay would be able to isolate & emotionally manipulate OP more effectively. Bob's actions inadvertently saved OP from potential abuse. He was the hero we needed in this story.

Story 2: BULLSHIT! I call BS! Either the last update, or the whole story, is such bullshit! Sooooooo fake, but IF it’s real, yeah that sucks. Everyone sucks, except the daughter I guess.

Second story: OP "I was the perfect wife, I may have cheated once, twice ok maybe threes time but he was good with it mostly, anyways here proof he's been cheating on me for months proving I was in the right all a long". If any of the update is true why was there no mention of taking him to the cleaners in the divorce now she has all this evidence of him cheating/grooming the daughter's friend?