Navigate Select ESC Close

Calm Down—Democrats WON the Shutdown! (w/ Will Saletan) | The Bulwark Podcast

2025-11-10 News & Politics
326.6k
19.3k
4.8k
The Bulwark
The Bulwark
1.7m subscribers

Analyzing Trump's Political Reality Following Shutdown Leverage and Weekend Events

Understand why Democrats secured crucial short-term political leverage in the recent shutdown despite online criticism, and see what the administration's latest actions reveal about its true priorities and political base.

Short Summary

  • Democrats sustained a long shutdown fight, achieving short-term concessions like extending SNAP benefits coverage.
  • Outrage over the final deal is largely dismissed as stemming from an "online" perspective, as the opposition party prioritizes intransigence over constituent pain.
  • Republicans exhibit severe message incoherence regarding policy, highlighted by their inability to articulate a clear healthcare plan beyond Trump's impulsive brainstorming.
  • Direct public rejection of Donald Trump via booing at an NFL stadium offered a moment of reassurance regarding the political backlash against his administration.

This discussion breaks down the political fallout after the government funding resolution, analyzing GOP messaging failures, the impact of recent mass pardons, and the significance of Trump's public rejection in Washington DC. It offers a strategic view on why loud, emotional support does not always equate to effective political victory when facing entrenched opposition.

Unlock all features

FREE: Get instant access to 10 AI summaries, chats, or transcripts per day.

Description

The very online crowd is very upset, but Dems did fight like Republicans. This was a longer shutdown than anything the Tea Party pulled and real pain was being caused. Democrats have now made the cost of healthcare front and center—while Republicans keep showing that they are the party of billionaires, Mar-a-Lago soirées, and golden ballrooms. Plus, President Al Capone pardoned all the people who tried to help him steal the 2020 election, pro-democracy Americans must stay united against the evil of the administration's deportation policy, and the effort to keep POTUS in a bubble really backfired Sunday night at the Commanders' stadium. Will Saletan joins Tim Miller. Show Notes: - Will on Trump's disregard for his party: https://www.thebulwark.com/p/no-one-matters-to-trump-but-trump? - Jon Chait on ending the shutdown without ending the filibuster: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/2025/11/democrats-shutdown-mistake/684878/? - The NYT on Venezuelans sent to CECOT in El Salvador: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/08/world/americas/el-salvador-prison-migrants.html - Book referenced by Tim, "Everyone Who Is Gone Is Here": https://bookshop.org/p/books/everyone-who-is-gone-is-here-the-united-states-central-america-and-the-making-of-a-crisis-jonathan-blitzer/d7d4a22ec001c9ff - F*%k your khakis and get The Perfect Jean 15% off with the code BULWARK15 at theperfectjean.nyc/BULWARK15 #theperfectjeanpod - Right now get up to 55% off your Babbel subscription at Babbel.com/BULWARK. - Start your new morning ritual & get up to 43% off your @MUDWTR at mudwtr.com/THEBULWARK! #mudwtrpod Become a Bulwark Youtube Plus Member here - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCG4Hp1KbGw4e02N7FpPXDgQ/join

Top Comments (10)

@StacyAnn456 2025-11-10

Love you Tim, but I hope you’re reading these comments. Millions of us (myself included) are losing healthcare because of this. The pain is very real for us “internet people”.

1.1k 88 replies
@Kurggen 2025-11-10

I'm on SNAP and Medicaid. Your suggestion that only people online who weren't suffering were willing to hold out longer. It's wrong to think americans who are hungry or sick would instantly cave, like we're weak We are as strong as any one.

771 37 replies
@JeffHole-wc1tc 2025-11-10

WTF? Anyone who no longer has access to affordable health care didn't win sh*t. Thousands and thousands were just handed a death sentence.

545 15 replies
@RayRayViper 2025-11-10

Its hard to giggle along with Tim when my local hospital in rural VA just announced theyre closing their OB/GYN dept. Now the closest L&D dept will be an hour away. There will be women and babies dying because of it. Listening to Tim laugh off our anger was just another slap in the face.

525 25 replies
@GabbaDabbaTracks 2025-11-10

I’m online and I’m a real person impacted by this shutdown AND impacted by the insane lawless actions of this Administration. This is maddening. A shutdown shows the chaos of a Trump presidency more clearly.

495 9 replies
@asianwoof 2025-11-10

You know why people are pissed at the golden ballroom? It's because all of these corporations were donating millions to its construction even while firing thousands of people to boost their bottom line.

478 15 replies
@Chalidriform 2025-11-11

Ask me how much of a win it feels like when I can no longer afford my cancer treatment in 2 months.

234 3 replies
@channelelyse 2025-11-10

There is no guarantee there will be a vote. And from their history, I say they just won’t even take it up on the floor.

177 8 replies
@jswift20 2025-11-11

the fact that “Raging Moderates” is more outraged than the bulwark by this is CRAZY!

153 11 replies
@501-ko 2025-11-11

You're right, I'm online watching the Bulwark too much. No more.

53 2 replies

Unlock the Data Inside
Turn Videos into Knowledge

  • Get FREE 10/day: transcripts, summaries, chats
  • Chat with videos, export text & PDF
  • $1 free API credit for RAG, chatbots & research

Free forever plan • All features unlocked

App screenshot