Navigate Select ESC Close

How "Speak No Evil" Misses The Point - A Comparison

2024-12-09 Entertainment
632.0k
38.3k
3.7k
The Critical Drinker
The Critical Drinker
2.5m subscribers

Unlock all features

FREE: Get instant access to 10 AI summaries, chats, or transcripts per day.

Description

Its a great, tension-fuelled psychological thriller, with a powerhouse performance from James McAvoy. The only problem is the ending, which completely misses the point of the Danish original. Join me as I compare the two, and explain why one is the perfect ending, and the other is Hollywood schlock.

Top Comments (10)

@0Midas0647 2024-12-09

So the original was a critique of what society is becoming, while the remake panders to it.

5.9k 68 replies
@Marshal_Dunnik 2024-12-09

"Why did you make me rewrite the final Act of this screenplay?" "Because you let me."

5.5k 32 replies
@benm5913 2024-12-09

It's poetic that the end of the remake is, literally, the reason why the original is thought-provoking in the first place.

4.0k 42 replies
@bloodrunsclear 2024-12-10

Original: Don't be a doormat. Remake: SLAY QUEEN!!!!

2.0k 13 replies
@Landofalcon007 2024-12-09

Man, that's some dark shit, that I would absolutely never want to watch. But that one line is a perfect summation of a certain modern view that thinks that people are basically good, and we all should just get along. "Why are you doing this?" "Because you let me". Simple as that. Evil doesn't respect anything but strength. You want peace? You better be ready and willing to fight for it.

1.9k 40 replies
@cowboyofscience7611 2024-12-09

The woman is the hero? Damn, I didn't see THAT one coming......

1.6k 38 replies
@jodown5584 2024-12-10

Learning to say "No" may be the most important lesson you can learn in life.

1.0k 10 replies
@ragnarok7976 2024-12-09

A cautionary tale about being weak bastardized by weak people. It's almost poetic.

605 7 replies
@DeltaDanner 2024-12-11

Kind of reminds me of Backcountry. It’s “based on” a true story about a couple out on a camping trip who get attacked by a bear. The bear mauls the wife and the husband fights it off with a pocket knife before carrying her all the way back to their car. Tragically, she died before getting to help. In the movie, the couple isn’t married and the boyfriend is an idiot who gets shown up by a handsome stranger before they go into the woods. He proposes, she rejects him, he gets mauled by a bear and she runs away before being rescued by the handsome stranger. It is mind boggling THE MESSAGE they’ll push when adapting stories, even true ones.

285 11 replies
@paulrippcord506 2024-12-11

The biggest problem I had with Speak No Evil is that it has absolutely no reason to exist. The Danish original is 95% in spoken English and it’s less than 3 years old. I get remaking a 25 or 30 year movie, especially if you can add something new to it, but something that recent. I’ve got sneakers older than The Guests.

69 4 replies

Unlock the Data Inside
Turn Videos into Knowledge

  • Get FREE 10/day: transcripts, summaries, chats
  • Chat with videos, export text & PDF
  • $1 free API credit for RAG, chatbots & research

Free forever plan • All features unlocked

App screenshot