Navigate Select ESC Close

The Race for the Next Generation of Rockets, with Jeff Thornburg

2025-10-07 Science & Technology
503.6k
11.8k
921
StarTalk
StarTalk
5.7m subscribers

Future of Aerospace: Engineering Challenges, Commercialization, and Propulsion Breakthroughs

Discover how aerospace engineers balance revolutionary concepts (like warp drives) with immediate commercial needs, and why public funding remains crucial for setting tomorrow's technological frontier.

Short Summary

  • The commercial space industry relies on private capital to generate profit, separating it from high-risk, foundational R&D best handled by government entities.
  • Iterative failure, when accepted by organizational culture, allows for faster development cycles compared to legacy programs demanding zero initial risk.
  • Proper risk communication requires leadership to formally document and accept accountability for known risks prior to launch or deployment.
  • National security depends on protecting space assets, as crucial civilian infrastructure like financial systems rely entirely on stable GPS timing.
  • Engineers drive civilization forward by solving problems within defined constraints; society must furnish them with the right challenges.

This discussion charts the path for transforming space travel by addressing propulsion limitations, managing political risk, and valuing iterative failure in engineering development. Aerospace engineer and CEO Jeff Thornburg shares insights from his experience at NASA, Aerojet, and SpaceX to illuminate the current trajectory of commercial space systems.

Unlock all features

FREE: Get instant access to 10 AI summaries, chats, or transcripts per day.

Description

What will the future of space look like? Neil deGrasse Tyson and comic co-host Chuck Nice explore the engineering challenges and scientific questions shaping the next era of aerospace with aerospace engineer and CEO of Portal Space Systems, Jeff Thornburg. From the Mars missions to the development of reliable, reusable rockets, we ask: how do we build spacecraft that are fast, safe, and simple enough to transform space into a true commercial frontier? We discuss the balancing act between government funding and private investment: why do we still need public dollars to seed technologies that don’t yet have a business case? Why is “failure” embraced by startups but avoided in legacy programs? And what lessons can be learned from disasters like Hubble’s flawed mirrors or the Mars Climate Orbiter’s metric–imperial mix-up? We explore reusable rockets, the tradeoff between fuel and payload, and the art of designing systems around unknowns. We also discuss the U.S.’s international competition in space and whether we can keep up. Why should citizens care about defending satellites, and what would it mean if GPS orbits were compromised? What propulsion breakthroughs could quantum physics unlock? Could solar-thermal engines or nuclear concepts make space travel faster and more sustainable? We discuss our dreams for the space industry. Will we ever achieve suborbital flights around Earth in 45 minutes, or treat the Moon as just another backyard destination? Thanks to our Patrons Adam Jensen, Eric Forde, Jaren Foreman, Robert Collier, Ryan Sanderson, Michael Franklin, Tiffiany Amber, MSegars, Clinton Hays, Rob, Wesley Michel, Aaron Wright, Vi Rose, James Sorensen, Jamie, David, Russell Knecht (Connect), John T McCoy, Ben Ryan, Fidel Roque-Flores, Eric walburn METZLER, Joseph Strasser, Daniel Ludlow, William Sacher, William Nowottny, Jay Sackett, Bryan Poole, Trevor Walter, Chiem Ma, Robert Rice, Lex Townes, Cavvote Landes, Franny, Keith Dickson, Bill Gallerani, Rosemary Taylor, Lisa Holloway, Jim Staub, Stiven Miranda, Erica, Jon Nebenfuhr, Ranjam69, David R Dykes, Micky Pistillo, Tony Toon, sr, April Lorenzo Spoor, Tom Randall, Jeff, Nico Cerceo, Sterling GRiffin, John, Red Shi, Pete Stoppani, Jonathan Hyatt, Dylan Moore, Shawn Kalas, Eric Dickinson, Kiela Badeaux, Leyna McGrath, Armaghan, bmanone, Much More Matt, Patrick Ritter, Laszlo Zoltan Buru, Indiigo, Isaiah, Brett Sklar, Brian Pickett, Micheal Kaplan, Cecilia, PopoMakBeth, and Shawn Best for supporting us this week. Timestamps: 00:00 - Introduction: Jeff Thornburg 03:50 - Maneuverability in Space 06:59 - Private Industry v. Government Projects 11:56 - The Challenges with Reusable Rockets 17:50 - Economics of Returning Rockets 20:37 - Engineering & The Value of Failure 28:12 - Acceptable Risk Management 31:50 - Big Space Engineering Blunders 34:14 - The Problem with the Cuts 36:30 - Running a Space Company 42:42 - History of Propulsion 47:21 - The US’s Vulnerability in LEO 53:12 - Fuel Efficiency in LEO 58:32 - What Engineers Dream About 01:02:07 - The Ultimate Goal of Commercial Space 01:03:49 - A Cosmic Perspective Check out our second channel, @StarTalkPlus Get the NEW StarTalk book, 'To Infinity and Beyond: A Journey of Cosmic Discovery' on Amazon: https://amzn.to/3PL0NFn Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/startalkradio FOLLOW or SUBSCRIBE to StarTalk: Twitter: http://twitter.com/startalkradio Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/StarTalk Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/startalk About StarTalk: Science meets pop culture on StarTalk! Astrophysicist & Hayden Planetarium director Neil deGrasse Tyson, his comic co-hosts, guest celebrities & scientists discuss astronomy, physics, and everything else about life in the universe. Keep Looking Up! #StarTalk #NeildeGrasseTyson

Top Comments (10)

@codygriffin8256 2025-10-07

I just started going back to school at 36 to get a degree in aerospace engineering lol 😅

912 128 replies
@predator42393n 2025-10-07

Please have Jeff come back, lets get some more engineers on Star Talk.

688 8 replies
@terryberger8992 2025-10-08

Finally, some engineering to back up the science. Worth every minute.

401 6 replies
@4thorder 2025-10-09

Retired Engineer here, and I am very pleased that you had an engineer on your show. The man is speaking my language :). During my time in R&D research for a major automotive company, I had the pleasure of accomplishing what was talked about here. Concept (thought in my head) through iterative design (80% good enough, test and collect data, tweak, repeat until it is close to best it can be) to final product. This allowed us to much more quickly get from one end to the other of the process. [Edit] - forgot to add in that there was no such thing as a failure if one learns from the data collected or feedback received. The test step of the aofermentioned process is in fact required. One does not know what one does not know. Testing simply reduces the unknowns, application of lessons learned improves the system.

213 10 replies
@ArunKarthikRavishankar 2025-10-08

Engineering is where the rubber meets the road. It's the filter that separates sci-fiction from sci-reality. Thx for this episode. I loved it. And I feel seen.

150
@Yutani_Crayven 2025-10-07

This should be mandatory viewing for anyone making space policy, and for a lot, a lot of space nerds.

125 2 replies
@kenkioqqo 2025-10-08

This has to be my new most favorite Star Talk episode yet. I could listen to Jeff talking about engineering for hours as I work.

106 2 replies
@OPB682 2025-10-11

This is one of the BEST podcasts you have done to date. Interview more ENGINEERS PLEASE

69
@skeller61 2025-10-07

Great to have an engineer in the house! Nice conversation, thanks….and to Neil and Jeff, too. There are so many things we take for granted, that wouldn’t be there without innovative engineers. Cheers.

55
@genelane2243 2025-10-09

Retired engineer here. I graduated from the Washington University School of Engineering and Applied Science. It took me a few years to understand that there are engineers and there are practitioners of applied science (also called engineers in many industries).

25

Unlock the Data Inside
Turn Videos into Knowledge

  • Get FREE 10/day: transcripts, summaries, chats
  • Chat with videos, export text & PDF
  • $1 free API credit for RAG, chatbots & research

Free forever plan • All features unlocked

App screenshot