Navigate Select ESC Close

Neutrons Are UNSTABLE, But They're EVERYWHERE! Why? Why? Why?

2025-02-28 Science & Technology
355.5k
15.5k
1.1k
Arvin Ash
Arvin Ash
1.1m subscribers

Unlock all features

FREE: Get instant access to 10 AI summaries, chats, or transcripts per day.

Description

Meet Arvin on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/arvinash REFERENCES Why everything tends to lower energy: https://youtu.be/pvPxCtrXT1c Why don't protons fly apart in a nucleus: https://youtu.be/WF2c_jzefKc Simplified quantum chromodynamics: https://youtu.be/KnbrRhkJCRk CHAPTERS 0:00 Why do neutrons exist? 1:16 Why do neutrons transform to protons? 2:02 How does mass play a role in stability? 3:28 Why are down quarks heavier than up quarks? 4;33 How the Higgs field determines mass 5:02 Why some particles interact more with Higgs field - Yukawa coupling 6:06 Why isn't the universe made only of protons? 7:00 Why are neutrons stable when bound in a nucleus? 9:34 How crucial important of this phenomenon: responsible for life! SUMMARY Why to neutrons exist? You may say, this is a silly question. But the problem is that we know that free neutrons are unstable. This means that if you isolate a neutron by itself, after about 15 minutes, it will spontaneously transform into a proton. So if that’s the case, and the universe is more than 15 minutes old, why isn’t the entire universe made only of protons? In fact, why does a free neutron decay to a proton in the first place? There's a good answer. But why is that answer correct? And why is the answer to THAT answer correct? We will keep why question over and over, until we reach a final answer. The reason a neutron transforms into a proton is because free neutrons are not stable. Protons are more stable because it is in a lower energy state. Free protons are more energetically stable than neutrons because they have a lower potential energy. Lower because they have a lower rest mass which is a form of potential energy. The reason protons have a lower rest mass is because they are made of lighter fundamental particles than neutrons. The reason a neutron's fundamental particles are lower mass is because they interact more strongly with the Higgs field, because their Yukawa couplings have higher value. We don't know why the Yukawa coupling is higher for down quarks? There are string theory explanations buty these have not been proven. In physics, until we have a theory of everything, every chain of why questions will ultimately lead to, “we don’t know” – and that’s okay because any I don’t know answer leads to more exciting science yet to be discovered by the next generation of scientists like you perhaps. But if protons have lower energy than neutrons, why do neutrons exist at all? Why isn’t the entire universe made of protons only? The answer is twofold, first not all neutrons early in the universe decayed after the Big Bang. Second, neutrons can be produced via weak force decays from protons. More about this in a minute. Why are neutrons more stable when bound in a nucleus with other protons than on their own? This is because the instability of a single neutron to decay to a proton is balanced against the instability that would be acquired by the nucleus as a whole if an additional proton were to participate in repulsive interactions with the other protons that are already present in the nucleus. Spontaneous processes such as neutron decay require that the final state is lower in energy than the initial state. In stable nuclei with protons and neutrons together, the neutrons act to make the nucleus more energetically stable. Why don't nuclei with two protons or two neutrons exist? Two protons together doesn’t work because the electromagnetic repulsion of two positive charges together makes it less energetically stable. One of the protons would transform to a neutron in that case via beta plus decay. #neutrons #nucleus A bound state of two neutrons is not stable because in order to be stable they would have to have the same spin, but that would violate the Pauli exclusion principle. One of the neutrons would transform to a proton in this case via beta minus decay, forming duterium. This spin state issue is not a factor with deuterium because the two particles are different.

Top Comments (10)

@mintysingularity 2025-02-28

Now I gotta know how a Neutron star remains stable.

608 119 replies
@FREQISZEXY 2025-02-28

Congrats on 1 million subscribers arvin

238 10 replies
@Sezstu 2025-02-28

This one explained a number of things I did not understand only to raise other questions no one understands. Beautiful!

183 5 replies
@FlyingJetpack1 2025-03-03

Nothing's more satisficing in a lecture than when you get a nagging question you want to ask, but then the lecturer comes back to address it before moving forward to the next bit without you even asking it. And this video is basically this feeling back to back in rapidfire, absolute bliss. Its an awesome format, keep it up!

63
@toney.vecchio 2025-03-02

1M subscribers! Thank you for all of the work and effort that you’ve put In time and time again on this project - your impact on our curiosity and on our own journey cannot be understated

50 1 replies
@jimmyzhao2673 2025-02-28

Me: Why Why Why ? Mom: Go ask Arvin Ash.

50 1 replies
@exharkhun5605 2025-02-28

There's a few channels that are quite good at this explaining thing, but you are seriously quite good at it.

35
@lungflogger9 2025-02-28

very nicely explained and the graphics were great!

26
@duggydo 2025-03-01

Great video Arvin. It's also nice and reminiscent of the old days to have a video without an ad in the middle. I know they are necessary, but they do disrupt the flow.

25
@MyChoice-now 2025-03-01

This is how university physics lectures should be Why Why Why Brilliant video

5

Unlock the Data Inside
Turn Videos into Knowledge

  • Get FREE 10/day: transcripts, summaries, chats
  • Chat with videos, export text & PDF
  • $1 free API credit for RAG, chatbots & research

Free forever plan • All features unlocked

App screenshot