Navigate Select ESC Close

Chevy Silverado EV vs. Ford F-150 Lightning: Big, All-American and Fully Electric Trucks

2024-12-27 Autos & Vehicles
177.2k
2.4k
742
Edmunds Cars
Edmunds Cars
618.0k subscribers

Unlock all features

FREE: Get instant access to 10 AI summaries, chats, or transcripts per day.

Description

The Chevy Silverado EV and Ford F-150 Lightning present different takes on the fully electric American full-size truck. While the Lightning is largely indistinguishable from its gas-powered sibling, the Silverado EV couldn’t be more different from the regular truck. But which approach makes the best electric truck? Find out with Edmunds’ Emme Hall in this electric truck comparison test! 00:00 Intro 01:00 Range & Efficiency 02:32 Driving Impressions 07:14 Comfort & Interior 10:11 Tech 12:50 Storage 14:12 Value 14:35 Edmunds' Take Subscribe to Edmunds https://www.youtube.com/user/edmundsvideo?sub_confirmation=1 for the latest car news, car reviews, car comparisons, car shopping and advice. Visit us! https://www.edmunds.com

Top Comments (10)

@aussie2uGA 2024-12-27

You have to wonder how much ford spent to develop a folding gearshift to “provide more room” when a console gearshift isn’t even needed.

242 29 replies
@mattbrew11 2024-12-27

I have 18 ford lightnings in my business fleet now and theyve been absolutely spectacular for my use case. So date all thats happened is one onboard charger failure and one tailgate step. A couple of them are nearing 100,000 miles already and if they had ~ 150 more miles of range id replace the rest of my half tons with them. Huge fan and initially I was pretty suspicious of how the first batch of ordere would work.

145 18 replies
@doyangk 2024-12-27

If you tow, larger battery size will matter more. You range will cut in half when you tow.

43 18 replies
@lc9935 2024-12-28

I've never been a truck guy but after test driving the lightning I was sold!

43 2 replies
@edmundscars 2024-12-27

Each one of these electric pickups have their strong suits – for example, the Silverado EV's impressive range and the Lightning's overall comfort. Which approach to the all-electric American full-size truck works better for you? Let us know in the comments.

12 11 replies
@GraphiteCA 2025-01-10

"A TRUCK that just happens to be electric" Exactly this. It's not a fashion statement, it's an F150 that's got batteries. And that's what I use to explain it to anyone who asks about mine. If it suits your use case (which it does for me!), it's amazing.

5
@bryankellyM 2024-12-29

Nice review Edmunds and right on the money from what I found in my own testing. I was in the market for an electric truck the whole year and have been waiting for the Ram Charger but I gave up hope due to all the delays. Recently, I test drove: Cybertruck dual, Rivian R1T dual with extended range, Silverado EV LT and the Ford Lightning Flash. IMO, the Rivian was the most fun and performed the best but I would have to go to Montreal every time I needed service from where I live (Northern NY) and I wasn't ready to do that for my needs. The Cybertruck grew on me after driving it around awhile but it needs some time to develop before it is market ready and I don't want to be a Beta tester for Tesla which made the Silverado EV and the Lightning the only two ev trucks I really was considering. Thankfully, Watertown NY had a snow storm the night before I had my test drive of the Silverado EV so I got to drive the 8600LBS beast in the 10" of snow and slush. The weight of the Silverado EV helps with pushing through the deep snow banks but the truck refuses to stop in braking due to the heavy weight and EV tuned tires. The 4 wheel steer isn't on the LT so the turning radius is huge on the LT. Anyway, I drove the Lightning Flash and it was great for all the reasons mentioned in the review. It's a very useable truck and even still has Apple CarPlay which is a big miss for Tesla, Rivian and GM for thinking the customers wouldn't miss it. I leased the Lightning for 2 years because I still think they are all over priced from where the technology will be in two years (i.e., the cost of these vehicles as used in 2 years), and it was a great deal too.

5
@jasonhawley5461 2026-01-25

Of the hundreds of car review videos I've watched - I love this reviewer! She is no BS and straight to the point. Thanks for being you!

3
@markfryar450 2025-02-19

Great review I just saw the Chevy in person for the first time yesterday it was awesome

0
@drivesanoldcar 2024-12-28

your reviews make a lot of sense and get in much info A+ approve of no sequay

0

Unlock the Data Inside
Turn Videos into Knowledge

  • Get FREE 10/day: transcripts, summaries, chats
  • Chat with videos, export text & PDF
  • $1 free API credit for RAG, chatbots & research

Free forever plan • All features unlocked

App screenshot